Prime Rib Steak VS Ribeye – What Cut Is Better (2020)

What comes to your mind when you hear “steak”? I’ll tell you what I think, pure joy!!! We can’t deny that steak from the prime rib is an incredible slab of goodness that we all enjoy every single time except when it goes wrong, but that’s what this article is about.

While some people do not know the difference between different types of steaks roast meat, we’ll be giving you more insight on the differences between the prime rib and the ribeye, which are the most confusing of all steaks meat, and it’s not just because they have similar names.

Steaks meat are cut out differently, which is one way to tell types of steaks apart, but today we’re focusing on making the process of learning about the prime rib vs. ribeye steaks as exciting and as informative as possible. Although the cuts of the rib eye and prime rib steak are also almost similar, they are not the same, and this article will be giving you a guide on their differences.

PRIME RIB STEAK AND THE RIBEYE, WHAT’S THE DIFFERENCE?

For most people, the difference between the prime rib, which is a roast steak and rib eye, is the method of preparation, but there’s more to it than just preparation of the rib prime and rib eye. They are both excellent rib steak cut’s that have been cut from the same prime rib part of a cow with almost the only difference being the presence of bone in rib prime and no or fewer bones in the ribeye steak. The prime rib and the ribeye may seem similar, but they have a different appearance and also a different method of preparation in the way they are cooked.

Prime rib steak has a bone, while rib eye steaks are almost boneless, and when it comes to being served, the prime rib roast and ribeye roast both have different cut portion sizes. Since the prime rib is a bigger roast, which the rib eye is often being cut out from, the prime rib has more fat and muscles than the ribeye steak.

They both have very distinct texture and flavor to them after preparation despite coming from the same part. Before we get in too deep on all of this, let’s try and gain an understanding of what and where the cut of prime rib and ribeye comes from.

What is PRIME RIB

The prime rib is also known as a standing rib roast. The roast comes from the same part of the animal that the ribeye steak does: the primal rib section. It is well-marbled throughout its roast meat, with the right amount of fat content that renders down as it cooks and roasts to keep the beef tender. Being one of the best cut of meat, one can buy, it is generally roasted in a standing position with the ribs stacked vertically and the layer of fat at the top, which flavors the meat you roast all the way through. The results are tender and delicious cut of prime rib roast meat, which is juicy and full of intense beef flavor. The bone-in adds more moisture and flavor.

Prime rib vs ribeye: RIBEYE

The ribeye is a juicy marbled steak cut from the center of the rib section and sold as bone-in or boneless rib roast. These are pretty forgiving steaks to cook because it has so much intermuscular fat; overcook it slightly, and it will still taste juicy. It has an abundance of fat that makes it moist and beefy in flavor. Ribeyes are a prime rib cut down into individual steaks. Ribeye is one of the most delicate parts cut from a cow and also has a marbling of fat that gives it a buttery and creamy taste. When cooked, the fat in the meat melts so that it thrashes the ribeye from the inside and enhances the juiciness and tenderness of the flesh.

Prime ribeye: WHAT MAKES PRIME RIB AND RIBEYE SIMILAR?

Besides having a similar name, the prime rib and the ribeye have their similar portions of meat coming from the same cut from the part of the cow, and it’s safe to say that you may not find significant differences in their essence. Still, they are both loaded with rich, beefy flavors thanks to their fat and muscle content which contributes to the turn out of the steak’s texture, so the only time there will be differences in the steaks is when they are cooked or when one roast them.

The prime rib to roast has an edge because it contains more bone and fat, in terms of flavor and choice of pick, the ribeye has advantages that come from being cooked with the bone, its taste isn’t far from the prime rib, and both have a distinct rich flavor typical of any other beef cut parts.

Ribeye roast vs prime rib: WHAT ARE THE DIFFERENCES BETWEEN THE PRIME RIB AND THE RIBEYE?

The differences between the prime rib for roast and the ribeye vary from the texture, cooking process, taste, and even the cost! If you have been reading attentively, we stated earlier; the most common difference is the prime rib steaks have a bone while the ribeye steaks are usually boneless.

Texture, Taste and Cooking Difference

The prime rib is a roast, and the ribeye is steak, so there is a significant difference in their textures when cut and prepared. The prime rib roast is generally cut into the desired shape and cooked at a lower temperature for some time with a preferred method of slow oven bake. At the same time, the ribeye is best pan-seared to an even medium-rare because they are often a bit thicker when cut than other kinds of steaks, we suggest a lower temperature in the oven to help reach the ideal temperature on the inside. The results are different both in appearance and in the way they are prepared and cut from the cow. The prime rib roast cut from the cow often contains large sections of the rib bone, while the ribeye steak is cut from the most tender part of the rib. We can say the flavor of seasoning is more potent in the prime rib cut because of the bones, fat and connective tissues in the cut and the meat.

The ribeye steak has a milder flavor and buttery taste with a smooth, melt-in-the-mouth texture. There are also significant differences in how they are cooked and served. Both prime rib and rib eye have very pronounced beefy flavors because of their location along the animal’s bone, even though the ribeye tends to be milder than the prime rib.

Cost Difference

One of the most significant differences between the prime rib roast and ribeye is the cost, based on the cut of the meat. Prime ribs often cost more because they have more marbling and flavorful than the ribeye steak and are, of course, cut in more significant portions, which makes one think of the cost of buying. Still, in restaurants, prime ribs are often cheaper than ribeyes because they are more comfortable for dining establishments to prepare more significant cuts of meat rather than making individual portions.

Is ribeye or prime rib better?

So sorry guys, but we cannot decide which is better between rib eye vs. prime rib, that is based on your choice and palate, but we will say that they are both of great flavor and texture, and preference plays a significant role in which you might prefer.

 Although, when ordering a prime rib, you’re going to get a cut of the roast and not the steak, so it’s best to stick to ordering the ribeye if you want a good steak or the best steak on the menu. In cases of holidays and occasions, the prime rib is best served.

Prime rib vs ribeye roast: When can you have Prime Rib and Ribeye?

As pointed out earlier, the best time for prime rib steak is on holidays and special occasions. That way, when you go shopping for steaks, you buy enough and make the right size and amount for everyone to avoid waste while you can enjoy ribeye steaks in diners or visits to restaurants. Steaks can be eaten at least one to three times a week, depending on moderation or purpose. You know what they say about overeating red meat and how it is unhealthy even though it is being seen as an essential dish for people who work hard or heavy-duty jobs or are trying to work on building up muscle and increase body mass.

Rib roast vs prime rib: Do Prime Rib and Ribeye have any Benefits?

While they’ve been talking about the unhealthy effects of too much red meat, in this case, prime rib and the rib eye, when we compare prime rib vs. ribeye, we will find out there are plus sides to having a steak on your menu. It provides you with the right amount of nutrients, one of which is protein, and as we know, protein is an essential nutrient for our body, which our body uses to build and repair tissues. Steaks also supply iron and zinc, which are essential micronutrients that are necessary for growth, development, and maintenance of immune systems and helps in protecting us from iron deficiency as well as preventing and curing infectious diseases. Steaks provide us with a healthy amount of fat and fatty acids that the body needs for energy and fun fact, it’s also a healthy way to work on that weight loss! The best way to enjoy these benefits of the roast is through moderation on how much we consume. The prime rib and rib eye steaks provide us with proteins and essential amino acids, which among other nutrients, are beneficial to the body.

Prime Rib vs. Ribeye with Wine?

All we can say to prime rib vs. ribeye is yes! Although, wine experts say it’s best to know the right wine to pair with your steak. But what’s the best wine to match the prime rib and the ribeye, you might ask? Not to worry, we got you covered. For the prime rib, might we suggest an exquisite glass of red wine, something simple for the meal, and the grilled roast ribeye a Cabernet Sauvignon? Not sure how you feel about what the experts are recommending, but be sure to give it a try and tell us what you think.

Ribeye vs prime rib – Conclusion

So, guys, this is where the steaks lesson ends; let’s have a quick recap, shall we? The prime rib and the ribeye have almost similar names but are two very different cuts of meat even though they are from the same primal part of a cow.

When we compare prime rib vs. ribeye, we find out that the prime rib is a juicy slice of a giant rib roast that is cut with the bone and best cooked at a lower temperature for an extended time. The ribeyes are marbled boneless steaks that have a tender buttery and smooth melt-in-the-mouth texture and are best pan-seared to an even medium-rare because they are often a bit thicker than other kinds of steak. If we compare the distinct methods of preparation of prime rib vs ribeye we will notice that it affects the texture and flavors of the steak.

But we did not stop there, we also talked about when to have steak, what situation or gathering is best for what type of steak, the amount of time you can have steak and the purpose for having steak on a regular basis while some have it for the satisfaction of palettes, others who work hard and probably heavy-duty jobs have it for strength due to the nutritional benefits and those who have steaks growth and enhancement of muscle and body mass even including a healthy weight loss. Steaks are unarguably beneficial in supplying nutrients to the body. We can say that “steak” is always yes!

Now that you’ve been enlightened on the significant differences between the prime rib vs. ribeye, the benefits when to have rib and rib eye steak, and even wine pairings, we hope you put this information to good use. When you go out and order a steak or decide to make your rib eye steak at home.