Best Charcoal Smokers Top Rated Reviews (2020)-Buy Small, Barrel or Vertical?

There is something about a charcoal grill that cannot be ignored when preparing grilled food. While it is very convenient to use other grills such as gas ones, there is an added unique flavor in the food prepared using a charcoal grill or smoking food. If you are looking for a convenient, reliable, and straightforward smoker for your barbecued food, the charcoal smokers available here might be all that you need for grilling and smoking.

It is essential to consider that they have stood the test of time. Most of them have been in the backyards of many houses all over the globe for decades. So both best charcoal grill and smoker are built to last. Moreover, if you consider one of the many smokers on the market that takes a longer time to cook to bring a homely feeling, we believe a charcoal grill could be what you have been looking for.

Using them at the back of your house may give time and space for people to socialize. Depending on the number of visitors you have, the best charcoal smoker and grill for your needs might differ. We understand that you may not have enough time to go through every detail that is out there concerning charcoal smokers.

For this reason, we have gathered relevant information about charcoal grills and smokers to ease your way through the choices. We have combined this information from different sources just to help you decide without much strain. Our sources are trusted and can be proven by the manufacturers and buyers of these items we have combined for you.

What Is The Best Charcoal Smoker?

We have invested a significant amount of time and money in investigating for you some of the best charcoal smoker or charcoal grill options on the market and how each can be used to meet your needs. We have gone through the reviews of people in their hundreds, tried and tested some of them. We talked to some professionals who are well versed in grills and smokers.

We have done this to understand each’s the tiniest detail to help you make a verdict of your own. In this article, we shall give the features that we believe are important to you before buying a smoker, whether for home or commercial use. This simplified version (all rights reserved) guides you in purchasing the most suitable option from the many American gourmet smokers on the market.

#1.Best Combination of Charcoal and Smoker: Royal Gourmet Charcoal Grill & Offset Smoker

Best Charcoal Smokers-Royal Gourmet Charcoal Grill & Offset Smoker


  • Combination charcoal grill and smoker
  • 800 square inches of cooking space
  • Side firebox for either charcoal grilling or smoker
  • Scald-proof handle
  • Adjustable fire grate

Rating: 4.3 out of 5 stars

The Royal Gourmet BBQ Charcoal Grill and Offset Smoker might be the right choice for you if you have a big or a small space. This is made possible because the stylish design makes it compatible with many areas available for you. Combining an offset smoker means an added advantage to you. This smoking machine provides an attached 184 square inches of cooking space for you in its special cooking chamber.

The mounted temperature gauge on the lid can help you better the experience you might have with grilling or smoking meat. You will be able to monitor the operating temperatures in the cooking chamber without much strain. Also, to help you with safety, the manufacturer has added a scald-proof handle to help you carry it even when it is hot inside. It might also be the solution for your children’s safety, as they are protected from excessive heat.

The adjustable steel fire grates that come with this model make it possible to tend to the fire without removing the grates and disturbing the heat. It can help you to save time and maintain the cleanliness that is needed in food preparation. Moreover, the cooking surface is large enough to accommodate many meat items, not forgetting that the offset smoker has additional space.

Adding on space, this model comes with a storage area that might help you access meat and other food that need to be smoked or grilled. Looking at its portability, we confirm that the manufacturers have catered to you. Two steel wheels are attached to it, making it look like a trolley that can be pulled with a lot of ease.


  • Easy to tend
  • Ample square inch space for smoking, grilling, and storage
  • Easily portable


  • Challenging to assemble parts

#2.Best Commercial Smoker: Dyna-Glo Wide Body Vertical Offset Charcoal Smoker

Best Commercial Smoker: Dyna-Glo Wide Body Vertical Offset Charcoal Smoker


  • 6 steel cooking grates
  • 1,890 square inches of cooking space
  • Pre-installed door seals
  • Off-set functionality

Rating: 4.2 out of 5 stars

The Dyna-Glo Wide Body Vertical Offset Charcoal Smoker offers one of the largest square inch cooking areas for the meat smoking business. If you are in the market for a smoking tool that can help cook many meals at a go, this might be what you need. Having six steel cooking grate fixtures in it, this charcoal smoker becomes an ideal tool for high volume cooking. You may not have to worry anymore if you have a Dyna- Glo wide-body model as a smoker.

The offset functionality is an added tool to make sure that cooking meat is easy and more efficient. It helps you in regulating the heat that is in the chamber to cook the food properly. In addition to this, the same function helps in the infusion of smoke in the food. It can help you adjust the taste of smoke that you may want in your meat. Looking at the size and the functionality of this charcoal smoker, we believe that it is relatively portable for anyone who may have it.

If you have an outdoor activity and you need smoked meat for a cookout, then this might be the kind of smoker you need. Depending on the size, it weighs between 57lbs and 123.4lbs. It can probably fit in your truck without much struggle. It is strong enough that you will probably not have to worry about things falling off or breaking parts from it. Testing it, we believe that it can serve you well, and it might be worthy of a trial.


  • Large cooking space (1,890 square inches)
  • Easy to maintain
  • Multiple functionalities


  • Hard to use for beginners

#3.Best Vertical Smoker: Dyna-Glo Vertical Charcoal Smoker

Best Vertical Smoker: Dyna-Glo Vertical Charcoal Smoker


  • 4 steel cooking grate elements
  • Large 784 square inches of cooking space
  • Stainless steel temperature gauge

Ratings: 4.3 out of 5 stars

The Dyna-Glo DGX780BDC-D 36″ Vertical Charcoal Smoker is a classic American gourmet smoking tool that can be advantageous to your kitchen. For those who love space and maybe you have many things you would want to cook at a go, this may be the solution for you. The smoker comes with 4 cooking grate options just for you to enjoy. It provides ample space for you to smoke extra meat for your family and friends.

See also  Best Smoker Charcoal Grill And Propane Gas Combo-Top Rated Reviews2020

If you are looking for an integrated smoker, we believe it is essential to check this American gourmet smoking tool. It comes with several features that might be of a positive addition to your smoking experience. Having a smoke chamber, you can control the amount of smoke that gets to your food while cooking for a unique taste. With it also, it is possible to control the heat within the chamber.

Are you the kind of person that likes neatness? Well, this Dyna-Glo Vertical Charcoal Smoker might be what you need. It is packaged together with a removable ash pan, water pan, a charcoal chamber, and charcoal grate. With every one of them separate, it is made possible for you to regulate each function that operates in it.

Testing the product, we confirm that the stainless steel used to make the smoker’s outer side is built to last. If you are tired of using charcoal smokers whose materials rust, then we believe that this product might be what you need. We have had ours for several months now, and it’s still looking like brand new even though it has been in our hands for months now.


  • It does not rust easily.
  • Large cooking area (784 square inches)
  • Easy to maintain


  • Minor heat leaks

#4.Best for Second Class Beginners: Char-Broil American Offset Smoker

Best for Second Class Beginners: Char-Broil American Offset Smoker


  • Charcoal grill option
  • 577 square inches of cooking space
  • Prep and storage space
  • Inbuilt temperature control

Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

The Char-Broil American Offset Smoker is one of the few tools on the market that can help you understand the basics of smoking meat for the desired result. Having ample square inch porcelain-coated cooking grates makes the cookout a clean activity. With this, you can make sure that your smoker will not rust. There is another advantage added to this. It makes the smoker more durable, therefore helps you to solve two problems. Having a lid-mounted temperature control gauge can be a good thing for you.

Without much strain, you can regulate the temperatures that are operating in the chamber. Moreover, a mounted temperature control gauge can help you monitor the temperature requirements for your food cooking in the chamber. Being in control over everything you are preparing can be a good thing. Having a large working area can be of great importance if you have many meat items to prepare. It can also be an advantage for you if you love large working areas.

The ash door that comes with this smoker offers an easy cleanup option. This is by opening the ash door and removing the dust from it. The smoke chamber also helps temperature control as well as smoke. It is essential to help you determine the amount of smoke you want to be infused in your meat. This is because different meats have different heat and smoke intakes for them to have a savory taste.


  • Easy mobility
  • Has good preparation area (577 square inches)
  • Comprehensive warranty


  • Some fragile materials

#5.Best Reasonable Manufacturing Materials: Cuisinart COS-118 Vertical 18″ Charcoal Smoker

Best Reasonable Manufacturing Materials: Cuisinart COS-118 Vertical 18" Charcoal Smoker


  • Ideal for all foods
  • Two air vents
  • Two tiers of smoking racks
  • 517 square inches of cooking space

Ratings: 3.8 out of 5 stars

Cuisinart is a known manufacturer who has been in the industry of making food smokers for some time now. The Cuisinart COS-118 Vertical 18″ Charcoal Smoker is one of the products that they have produced. If you are looking for a food smoker that can serve all your meat at one go, maybe this is the answer you need. It has been built to precision to help smoke all types of foods from cheese to meat.

It is also easy to set it up. It has a new porcelain water pan to hold water. This makes it easier to access the things you may need when you are preparing your meal. In addition to the above, this Cuisinart smoker has a more natural moderation of smoke and heat required for your meal to be termed as well prepared.

Two air vents have been strategically placed to make it possible for you to control heat and smoke allowed to leave the chamber. For easy maintenance and cleanup, they added simple features such as a curved area to clean the surface. This can help you to maintain your smoker for longevity.

Coming with two racks in it, the Cuisinart smoker creates more space for you to smoke your favorite meat for family or friends. It leaves room for more meat or any other food you may want to smoke for a complete meal. If you are looking for a home charcoal smoker, this might be the solution you need.


  • Has a water pan
  • More control over smoke and heat
  • Easy to maintain
  • Ample space (517 square inches)


  • Hard to maintain high temperatures for long hours

#6.Best Engineered Smoker: Char-Griller E1224 Charcoal Grill with Side Fire Box, Black

Best Engineered Smoker: Char-Griller E1224 Charcoal Grill with Side Fire Box, Black


Rating: 3.9 out of 5 stars

The Char-Griller Smokin’ Pro BBQ Smoker might be an ideal tool for you. It has been manufactured for the user convenience to leave a long-lasting impression of satisfaction. If you are looking for a smoker that will distribute heat evenly, we believe that this can be the brand you have been looking for. We tested it, and we confirmed that this feature could be trusted.

To avoid warping, the manufacturer ensured that the materials used are non-other than cast iron and non-stick. The adjustable fire grate on this smoker is a classic. It offers a wide range of adjustment levels, all for you to enjoy. Worrying about heat not reaching your food or being too close to it can be solved by this feature. It gives you the user confidence even without seeing the results.

Going through the reviews in detail, we confirmed that this Char-Griller Smokin’ Pro BBQ with a smoker has a large area for grilling and smoking meat. For those who are in love with barbeques as a business or enthusiasts, this can be the solution for you.

The feature makes this model of smoker very versatile in the market. If you have been looking for ample smoking and grilling space for your food, we believe this could be the answer. You can put many significant items in the cooking space and expect them to cook within a short time.

The heat gauge added to it can help you regulate the temperatures in the quest for a well-prepared meal for your visitors or customers.


  • Easy to use
  • Large cooking area
  • Good temperature regulation


  • Minor leaks of smoke

#7.Best Stable Vertical Smoker: Real Cook Vertical Steel Charcoal Smoker

Best Stable Vertical Smoker: Real Cook Vertical Steel Charcoal Smoker


  • Functional access doors
  • Chrome-plated cooking grid
  • Built-in thermometer
  • Extra strong legs for stability

Rating: 4.0 out of 5 stars

The Real cook Vertical Steel Charcoal Smoker is foundational equipment for anyone who desires to have a unique flavor added to food. Are you looking for a smoker that has quality protection? Well, this might be what you have been looking for all the time. It has a built-in thermometer and a detailed temperature scale that is without a match. This can help you monitor your food all the time to avoid the frustration of burning your food. The additional heat resistant handles can raise your confidence in safety even with children around you.

The Real cook Vertical Steel Smoker also comes with a good space for cooking two items at a go. With this kind of a functional feature, the worry you might be having of not preparing your smoked dish on time might be averted. The multifunctional feature added to this smoker could aid you more in food preparation. Using it, you can smoke both cold and hot food to add charcoal smokers’ unique flavor.

See also  Best Smoker Grill for Beginners - Top Rated Review (2020)

Using this Real cook Vertical Steel Smoker can be one of your most suitable decisions concerning acquiring durable kitchenware. It has two access doors. The advantage of this is to help you check the right thing at your convenience. If you want to check the charcoal or wood chips’ status, you can open the lower one and decide on the next step. If you need to check how your food is cooking, you just open the upper lid. This easiness saves you time.


  • Easy access
  • Easy temperature moderation
  • Multifunctional property


  • Minor smoke leaks

#8.Best Char-Broil American Smoker: Char-Broil Bullet Charcoal Smoker

Best Char-Broil American Smoker: Char-Broil Bullet Charcoal Smoker


  • Innovative airflow
  • Durable construction
  • Convenient removable ash pan
  • Temperature gauge

Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

The Char-Broil Bullet Charcoal Smoker has been in the heart of America since the year 1948. It has been one of the most preferred charcoal smokers and has stood the test of time. During the time we were going through the reviews of charcoal smokers on the market, we came across this and found it worthy of a trial. Testing and asking questions to the professionals, we discovered the following.

Char-Broil Bullet Smokers are convenient and might be the solution that you have been looking for. The innovative design makes the airflow well and helps in the regulation of temperatures. This is a feature that might drive your fears away from ever getting your smoked food burnt. Char-Broil Bullet Smokers also have a removable ash pan, which is easy to use.

This will probably help you maintain your cooking’s cleanliness, therefore helping you control this. It also comes with a sealing door in the fire access point that aids in sealing the smoke needed to add a savory taste in smokers. The porcelain-coated cooking grates have two essential features that might be of help to you.

First, they give you the user ample space to help you cook more food at once. This can help you accommodate more visitors for a treat without worry. Secondly, these smokers come with a well-built interior for longevity. The latter helps you not to worry about the future in case it gets broken. High-quality smokers will help you in saving some money.


  • Trusted durability
  • Innovative airflow control
  • Infusing smoke flows


  • Minor smoke leaks from the lid

#9.Best Weber Smoker: Weber 711001 Smokey Mountain Cooker Charcoal Smoker

Best Weber Smoker: Weber 711001 Smokey Mountain Cooker Charcoal Smoker


  • Plated steel cooking grates
  • Built-in lid thermometer
  • Easily adjustable dampers
  • Rust-resistant metal legs

Rating: 4.8 out of 5

The manufacturers of this smoker, Weber, is one of the most trusted smokers worldwide. They attached importance to the slightest detail that has been one of their key factors of success. Looking at this Weber smokey mountain cooker, perfection can be seen from a distance. If you desire to slowly make a savory smoked meal as your visitors trickle into your backyard to taste the goodness, we believe that smokers like this one might be what you have been looking for.

Whether you are looking for a home cooking solution or a business one, Weber smokers have got you covered in all directions. The smokers come in three distinct sizes: 14-Inch, 18-Inch, and 22-Inch. Therefore, you can choose which suits your needs. The porcelain plated lid, bowl, and center section of these smokers are parts that retain heat without peeling or rusting.

The Weber 711001 has two grated sections to give the user ample space to simultaneously smoke two different items. The built-in lid thermometer helps in monitoring internal temperatures. In addition to this, Weber smokers have an adjustable fuel door that comes off to allow fuel, either charcoal or wood chips.

When it comes to carrying them, the mobility is helped because the weight lies between 23-68 pounds, depending on the size you pick. If you wondered where to source a smoker to travel with for outdoor activities, this Weber charcoal cooker might be what you need.


  • Easy to use
  • Easy to assemble
  • Easy to adjust temperatures


  • Minor air leaks

Buying Guide for Best Charcoal Smokers

While you are searching for a charcoal smoker, it is key that you consider several factors. They range from the need you have, space where you want to put your smoker, the money you have, the times you use, the amount of food you need prepared, and the portability you require, among many others. If you are interested in grills, you might consider our pellet grill reviews too.

For example, if you need a smoker for a small nuclear family cookout, you need a smaller one than someone who hosts many people for a cooking event or maybe in business. The trust you have for a certain seller might also come into play as many people tend to buy smokers from people they trust.

Reasons Why You Should Consider Buying a Charcoal Smoker

Food is considered a basic need for every human being. It, therefore, means that going without food for many days may lead to death. Apart from this essential fulfillment, the cooks involved always want to make the food tastier than before. Have you ever wondered what the best vertical pellet smoker is? We made an article for you you can read right now. Different foods require different methods of preparation. Some require frying. Others require boiling, while others require grilling and smoking.

To meet this need of bringing the best in every meal, having a smoker in your possession can help a lot. Besides, eating meals together with other people has proven over time to be a perfect way of bonding. Thinking of the best way to make this happen, you cannot be ignorant that smoking food using a smoker can be a significant path to achieving this. Keep reading the charcoal smoker guide for an in-depth examination of remarkable smokers you can buy right now.

Factors to Consider in the Purchasing of a Charcoal Smoker

When buying a charcoal smoker, it is essential to consider several factors to decide on the items’ best pick flooding the market. Hey, we know that you are interested in charcoal smokers, but you might check out our article about the best smokers as well. Below are some of these points to consider before purchase:

Size of the cooking surface

When buying a charcoal smoker, the cooking surface is essential, considering the space you need for your meals to cook well. Some come with an extensive area for cooking many items, while others come with a relatively smaller space. If you are looking for ample cooking space, it would be wise to consider a smoker such as the Dyna-Glo DGX780BDC-D 36″ Vertical Charcoal Smoker, which has 4 grates. If you consider a smaller cooking area, the Weber 711001 Smokey Mountain Cooker 14-Inch Charcoal Smoker will work best for you as it has two grates.

Price of the charcoal smoker

The size of your pocket or the amount of money you are willing to invest determines the product you consider buying. The different prices are brought about by ranging factors such as size, the materials used, the company, and sometimes even the distance the product is being shipped, among many others. Don’t hesitate to take a look at our offset smoker for sale too! If your budget isn’t that high, maybe you should consider a product like the Char-Broil Bullet Charcoal Smoker, 16,” which is relatively affordable compared to those costing over $400.

Charcoal wood smokers – Ease of maintenance

It is of great importance to consider how easy it is for you to maintain a charcoal smoker. This is mainly because it deals with food for human consumption that requires a high level of cleanliness. This is metered by the type of materials used. Some may be prone to rust, which is terrible for food preparation. Therefore, it is vital to look for a product that can keep your meals preserved well.

See also  Best Large Electric Smoker - Big, Huge, Giant and Tall (2020)

Charcoal smoker reviews – Durability

Another factor that you can consider is the longevity of the smoker you are about to buy. It is often difficult to know how durable a product is. One of the tips we have gathered to help you is by looking at the reviews and the ratings. Feel free to check out our smoker grill combo article that you might find interesting. There is a high likelihood that the ones with a lower score may not be durable enough, while the opposite is also exact.

For example, a product like the Char-Broil Bullet Charcoal Smoker, which has a 4.5 out 5 stars rating, may be more durable than the Char-Griller E1224 Charcoal Grill with the Side Fire Box, which has a 3.9 out of 5 stars rating.

Best barrel smoker – Warranty

If a smoker breaks down due to manufacturing problems, the manufacturer is obligated to fix it for you free of charge. However, different manufacturers have different time frames for this, and it is crucial to find out these time frames even before purchase. If you are going into business, the warranty factor comes in handy, and in our view, it should be at least two years so that it may give you a service of considerable returns.

Charcoal and wood smokers – Portability

Some people travel a lot for cookouts, and some love doing it in their houses’ backyard. Considering these two different clients, it is reasonable if the latter considers buying something less mobile than the former. It is because the two have different needs. The portability aspect is combined in many things, such as the size and the weight and the added accessories such as wheels.

Check out the beginner smoker recipes here. If you desire to have a more portable charcoal smoker in your possession, it would be wise if you considered a product such as the Char-Broil Offset Smoker, 30″ which has wheels for mobility.

Small charcoal smoker – Functionality

When buying a charcoal smoker, it is vital to consider the different functions that the tool can serve. Different manufacturers have various features infused in their products. It will be of great advantage for someone in the commercial world to have a smoking area and a grilling area. The two functions might serve you well because you would not need to go the extra mile of buying a separate grilling machine while you can purchase them in one package. If you are that kind of a client, you should consider purchasing the Royal Gourmet Barbeque Smoker & Grill.

Charcoal smokers – Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

What brand of a smoker is the best?

When choosing the best charcoal smokers on the market, it is essential to note an infusion of different factors to consider. If you need a small charcoal smoker, finding a product that has relatively small dimensions can be the best thing for you, while for a person who might need a large working area, considering one that measures high would be the best thing to do.

The two extremes have different ways of finding the best brand. We believe that you need to identify your needs first before purchasing to get that which suits you well. Do you find charcoal smokers interesting? You might also find gas smoker appealing, so take a look at our review. You can also check on the ratings to consider which brands are more popular than others and why.

What is the best charcoal smoker for the money?

Considering the amount of money, you are willing to invest in it and the return you expect can be a good start. Different charcoal smokers have different efficiency depending on what the manufacturer considered when building it. Looking at the reviews of other buyers, we can gauge some’s effectiveness compared to others. For example, if you are willing to invest over 200 dollars for a charcoal smoker, it should at least be stable enough for portability, large enough to allow cooking, and durable enough to stand the test of time.

How do you keep a charcoal smoker hot?

There are several ways we have tried and tested to keep the smoker hot. We advise that you should consider buying a smoker that has a detailed and functioning temperature gauge. It is the first step to monitor the dropping of temperature, signaling you to add more fuel. If you already have a malfunctioning temperature gauge, we advise that you consider buying an additional thermometer from the store.

The most popular one being an air probe. It will help you monitor and control the temperatures inside the chamber. One other way you can consider is opening the dampers; the free circulation of oxygen can increase the chamber’s temperatures, thus improving its hotness.

What is the best smoker for beginners?

For beginners, it would be important to consider several factors before buying a smoker. We advise that you consider prioritizing your needs first. This would help you in determining the most suitable tool for you. It is essential to think of something affordable, simple, and small, so you may learn how to prepare meals well.

Best charcoal smokers – Conclusion

Our top three picks for the day are, first, the Weber 711001 Smokey Mountain Cooker 14-Inch Charcoal Smoker. It has the highest rating in our listing, with 4.8 out of 5 stars. It is easy to use and assemble. Its fast weight makes it portable over long distances to picnic grounds.

The porcelain walls have a way of containing temperatures within the chamber. Also, it enables the user to control the temperatures within the chamber. Moreover, the tool comes as a well-coated item of work as the materials used are durable and easy to maintain.


In the runner-up position, we have the Char-Broil Bullet Charcoal Smoker, 16″. The unique, innovative airflow that is built in the smoker is worthy of consideration. It helps in regulating temperatures more quickly and efficiently than other charcoal smokers. This increases the confidence that you can trust this product when it comes to sensitive cooking.

The porcelain wall bears witness to its durability as well as being rustproof. With these in the same unit, it is of great importance to note that it might be worth a trial if you are willing to invest the amount of money required.

The third one here is the Dyna-Glo Vertical Smoker, which comes with an inbuilt stainless temperature gauge that has proven to be ideal for significant accuracy. Having ample cooking space for cooking is also advantageous for you if you consider it commercial or large-scale usage. It is because it boasts 4 grates that can be adjusted, creating more room for items to be added for cooking.

Looking at the article above, it is clear that there are many factors that you need to consider before purchasing one of the best charcoal smokers or charcoal grills. Each of the charcoal grills and smokers has advantages and disadvantages, and this can help you understand that there is no perfect product out there in the market as there are no ideal people.

However, there are those smokers that have many advantages compared to their cons. This sets them apart and helps you to consider what you require. As cliché as it may sound, different manufacturers satisfy different needs. Therefore, we are here to help you know some of the essential details that we believe you need for a successful purchase.